HOA dues are not just an extra expense. Lenders treat them like a debt obligation when calculating your debt-to-income ratio. That math can quietly remove tens of thousands of dollars from the home price you can qualify for. Here is how one buyer ran into the wall, and how she adjusted.
Important: this is an anonymous illustrative example, not a real client. All figures are educational ranges. Your actual results will depend on credit, income, property, and current program guidelines. This is not a commitment to lend or guarantee of approval.
The buyer (anonymous): a first-time buyer in a desirable Sacramento suburb. Pre-approved for around $525,000 based on her income, credit, and standard DTI calculations.
The trigger: she fell in love with a townhome listed at $475,000 with a monthly HOA dues of $400.
The surprise: the lender re-ran her qualification with the $400 HOA included. Her maximum qualified loan amount dropped significantly.
Lenders calculate debt-to-income (DTI) ratio by comparing your gross monthly income to your total monthly debt obligations. Total debt obligations include:
An HOA payment of $400/month adds approximately $4,800/year to your housing expense. For a typical FHA or conventional DTI cap, that $400 monthly fee can reduce your maximum qualifying loan amount by tens of thousands of dollars depending on your income and rate environment.
Original pre-approval: up to approximately $525,000 in purchase price with no HOA.
After the $400 HOA was factored in: maximum qualifying purchase price dropped by roughly $50,000-$70,000, depending on the property tax rate and insurance estimates in that area.
The townhome she loved at $475,000 with the $400 HOA was now uncomfortably close to her DTI ceiling. Doable, but tight.
Option A: Shop in a similar price range without HOA. Single-family homes (no HOA) at the same price unlock the full original buying power.
Option B: Shop a smaller home with HOA. A condo or townhome at a lower price keeps the HOA but the smaller loan amount fits within DTI.
Option C: Reduce other monthly debts. Paying off a car loan or aggressive credit card paydown frees DTI capacity for the HOA.
Option D: Increase income on the application. A second-job W-2, bonus income, or rental income that can be documented may expand qualification.
Option E: Larger down payment. A larger down payment lowers the proposed loan amount and the monthly payment, freeing room for the HOA.
She ran the math on Options A through E. The combination that worked: she negotiated $400 in seller credits to apply toward a rate buydown, which lowered her Year-1 payment enough to leave comfortable margin against the HOA. She also paid off a small auto loan, which freed roughly $300/month in DTI capacity.
End result: she closed on the townhome she wanted, at the price she could comfortably support, with a sustainable monthly payment.
HOA dues do build value: they fund shared amenities, exterior maintenance, insurance on common areas, and (in many cases) roofing, landscaping, and pool/clubhouse maintenance. That said, HOA dues are not equity-building. Every dollar paid in HOA dues is gone, just like rent.
For some buyers, that trade-off is worth it: the lifestyle, the predictable maintenance, the amenity package. For other buyers (especially long-term wealth builders), the no-HOA single-family route compounds equity faster. The right answer depends on your goals, your budget, and what you actually value about your home.
Because HOA dues are a legally required, ongoing monthly obligation tied to the property. Skipping them can result in liens, fines, and ultimately foreclosure. Lenders treat them like any other recurring housing obligation.
Sometimes yes, prepaid HOA dues can be part of a closing-cost credit negotiation. But it only buys a few months. The dues will resume after the prepaid period.
Standard recurring assessments yes. One-time special assessments (e.g. roof replacement, building repairs) are typically not, unless they are formally being amortized monthly. Always read the HOA financials before buying.
No. HOAs deliver value: shared maintenance, insurance, amenities. The question is whether the value to you exceeds the cost AND the DTI impact. Run the math both ways.
Use the HOA Impact Calculator on the site. Plug in a candidate HOA fee and see how it changes your qualifying loan amount in real time.
This page describes a hypothetical, anonymous example for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend, guarantee of approval, or guarantee of any specific result. All figures shown are illustrative ranges based on typical scenarios; actual results depend on credit, income, property, occupancy, current program guidelines, market conditions, and underwriting review. No specific rates, payments, or program eligibility are promised. Equal Housing Opportunity. PRMG Mortgage. NMLS 225375. Ken Clark Jr. NMLS #225375.
Certified Mortgage Advisor and Branch Manager at PRMG Mortgage (NMLS #75243). 28 years in mortgage lending. Specializes in FHA, VA, conventional, DPA, jumbo, Non-QM, renovation, and construction financing for buyers and investors in Sacramento, New Jersey, and 47 other states (NY excluded). Three-time Gold Award winner for Best Mortgage Company in Sacramento (2023, 2024, 2025). NMLS #225375.
Verify Ken's license at NMLS Consumer Access · Read client reviews · Schedule a call